Arbitration awards under the federal ban on surprise medical bills added an estimated $8.39 billion to employer health‑plan obligations in 2025, according to new research from the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI). The figure equals roughly 63 cents for every $100 of employer health‑plan spending, or about 0.625% of the $1.34 trillion spent annually on job‑based coverage.
The Bottom Line
The No Surprises Act, enacted in 2020, shields patients from balance billing when they receive out‑of‑network emergency or certain non‑emergency care. When insurers and providers cannot agree on payment, either side can invoke the Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process, a form of baseball arbitration in which an arbitrator selects one party’s offer in full with no splitting the difference. The $8.39 billion represents the net additional amount employer plans owed out‑of‑network providers after arbitration awards, above initial plan payments and patient cost‑sharing.
By the Numbers
CMS data show that 2.56 million IDR disputes were initiated in 2025, far exceeding the agency’s original projection of about 22,000 cases per year. The arbitration process does not split the difference; the arbitrator selects one party’s offer in full, often resulting in payments that exceed the median in‑network contracted rate, known as the Qualifying Payment Amount (QPA). EBRI calculated the IDR uplift — the winning award minus the plan’s initial payment and the patient’s cost sharing — directly from CMS public‑use files for the third quarter onward. For the first half of the year, when those fields were not yet available, EBRI estimated the uplift using the QPA as a proxy. Sensitivity tests using $500,000 and $100,000 cutoffs produced estimates of $8.38 billion and $8.02 billion, respectively.
Why the No Surprises Act Created This Liability
The law generally prohibits providers from billing patients beyond their normal in‑network cost‑sharing amounts and requires plans and providers to resolve any remaining payment dispute between themselves. If negotiation fails, either party may escalate to the federal IDR process. Because the arbitrator must choose one offer outright, the mechanism can produce awards above the QPA, especially when providers submit higher offers and insurers submit lower ones. Employers and insurers argue that the high volume of disputes and generous awards are driving up plan costs, which are ultimately reflected in higher premiums for workers.
Stakeholder Reactions
Industry groups such as the Coalition Against Surprise Medical Billing have asked CMS to halt recertification of IDR entities until the process is reformed, citing bias toward clinicians. Physician organizations including the American College of Emergency Physicians, the American College of Radiology, and the American Society of Anesthesiologists counter that insurers offer unrealistically low payments, use flawed QPAs, and impose impractical contracting terms to avoid fair payment. On November 4, 2026, CMS announced it would not recertify two IDR entities — Island Peer Review Organization, Inc. (dba IPRO) and Network Medical Review Company, LLC — stating that entities must continue to meet certification standards for timeliness, accuracy, independence and impartiality.
What Comes Next
Recent rule changes limit batching to 50 line items and cut the administrative fee to $15 per party per dispute, effective August 3, but the core arbitration mechanism remains unchanged. Pivotal Health Technologies Inc. has added Forbes Tate Partners to its lobbying roster to work on No Surprises Act enforcement and IDR updates, joining DLA Piper and Liberty Partners Group. CMS reports 750,022 disputes initiated and 784,352 closed for August and September alone.
Sources
- Balance billing
- Q&A: Inside the Battle Over the No Surprises Act IDR Process | DocWireNews
- No Surprises Act Arbitration Added $8.39B in 2025 Plan Obligations | AJMC
- No Surprises Act IDR process adds $8.39bn to health plan costs
- No Surprises Act is adding $8.39bn to employer health plan costs
- Pivotal Health Adds Forbes Tate to Lobby on No Surprises Act
Photo: Beatriz Cattel / Unsplash (Unsplash License)





