Health breakthroughs and money matters, in plain words

Home » Moral Hazard Shapes Insurance Decisions, Even for Lifestyle Drugs

Moral Hazard Shapes Insurance Decisions, Even for Lifestyle Drugs

By

–

Moral Hazard Shapes Insurance Decisions, Even for Lifestyle Drugs

Does having insurance make people a little less careful? Economists and insurers have argued about that for well over a century, and they gave the worry a name: moral hazard.

The economist Paul Krugman defines it as “any situation in which one person makes the decision about how much risk to take, while someone else bears the cost if things go badly.” A homeowner with fire cover may take a little less care. A company that expects a government rescue may chase bigger risks. Studies find that insured patients, above all those paying almost nothing out of pocket, ask for unnecessary medical care more often than uninsured ones.

Where the phrase came from

The term started in the insurance trade, and early on it was not kind. In 1895 the economist John Haynes described moral hazard as a “lack of moral character,” with arson as the familiar example. Yet the same writer saw further than that. He noted that insurance can reduce effort and encourage carelessness, and that people could overestimate a loss without any dishonesty at all.

Insurance writers in the early twentieth century were harsher. In 1907 H.P. Blunt argued that leading insurers should keep a class of immigrants off their books, since a policy held by them could tempt someone to crime. Later insurance texts blamed ethnic and social groups. The prejudice was plain. As researcher David Rowell notes, economists took a different line, seeing incentives where insurers saw bad character. Alfred Marshall had already written in 1890, without using the phrase, that insurers must price in carelessness and fraud.

Frank Knight stretched the idea to company structures in 1921. Then in 1963 Kenneth Arrow made the case that government should step in where markets for medical insurance fail to form, with moral hazard as one reason. A new generation of economists took notice.

A label with weight

Today the concept turns up in workers’ compensation, disability benefits, stock markets and even family behavior. Rowell goes so far as to say that hardly any corner of economics escapes it. Inside insurance, an older taxonomy survives: “moral hazard” meaning evil character, and a separate “morale hazard” meaning carelessness caused by being covered. What insurers call morale hazard is what economists, from Arrow onward, call moral hazard.

The wording still matters. The lawyer Tom Baker has argued that the economics of moral hazard can be used to justify withholding help from the sick and poor, on the logic that help breeds irresponsibility. Philosophers find that reasoning morally suspect and hold that anyone in need deserves help where possible. Dembe and Boden made a related point in 2000: the idea is so entrenched in economics that few stop to ask what the word “moral” implies.

One of the best-known examples is the Deepwater Horizon well. Some experts contend that BP drilled it partly because the 1990 Oil Pollution Act limited its liability for damages from a spill to $75 million.

Sources

Get breaking stories first on our Telegram channel.

More stories by

Most read

Health & Medicine

Personal Finance

Cancer News

Health News