Robert had about $500,000 spread across three retirement accounts, and the IRS wanted some of it out. He did not need a dime for his bills. So he called The Clark Howard Show with a question: what do I do with money I am forced to take?
The exchange dates to the February 7, 2018 broadcast, and a personal finance column published by 247wallst.com on June 27, 2026 revisited it. Robert told Howard he was past 70.5 and was splitting his required minimum distribution across all three accounts.
Howard’s answer was short. “If you don’t want to give it away to family or charity or you don’t want to do something fun for yourself and you don’t need the money. This is going to sound weird. I would put it into an investment account and I would buy like a total stock market index fund or something like that with it,” he said. “There would be ultimately a great inheritance asset for somebody to get way down the road.”
The column’s author called that instinct correct. Money nobody needs, the piece argued, belongs in an investment rather than a checking account where inflation eats at it. But the author also said Howard left something out.
The tax bill comes first
Every dollar pulled from a traditional IRA or 401(k) counts as ordinary income. For a married couple filing jointly in 2026, the column said, that income lands on top of Social Security and pension payments and is taxed at 22%. The bill arrives whether the cash pays for groceries or sits in a savings account earning 4%.
The column ran the numbers on a hypothetical. Say Robert’s combined RMD is $20,000 and his marginal rate is 22%. He owes about $4,400 in federal tax regardless. The remaining $15,600, placed in a total market index fund inside a taxable brokerage account, can compound for years. Index funds throw off mostly qualified dividends and long-term capital gains, both taxed at preferential rates. At death, heirs receive a stepped-up cost basis, which wipes out the unrealized gains.
The same $15,600 left in a high-yield savings account fares worse, the column said. Interest is taxed as ordinary income every year.
Where Howard stopped short
For retirees who give to charity, the column pointed to a Qualified Charitable Distribution. A QCD sends money straight from an IRA to a charity, up to $108,000 under the 2025 limit. It satisfies the RMD and never shows up on the tax return.
That matters because of the standard deduction. At $29,200 for 2026, it leads most retirees to skip itemizing, so an ordinary donation earns no tax benefit. Howard did mention giving to family, and the column said that still works. The 2026 annual gift exclusion is $19,000, so Robert and his spouse could give $38,000 to each adult child or grandchild without gift tax paperwork. The catch is that Robert would already have paid income tax on the RMD before giving it away.
What has changed since 2018
The 70.5 threshold Robert cited is gone. Under SECURE 2.0, RMDs now begin at age 73, rising to 75 in 2033. Someone who turned 73 this year has a first distribution due by April 1 of next year.
The column’s checklist for retirees in Robert’s position included taking the withdrawal from the lower-volatility part of the portfolio, as Howard advised, and sending any charitable money through a QCD before December. It also suggested asking custodians such as Schwab, Fidelity and Vanguard to set up monthly automatic RMDs, which spreads market-timing risk across the year.
Sources
- Robert, Past 70.5, Asks Clark Howard What to Do With RMDs From Three Retirement Accounts
- Robert, Past 70.5, Asks Clark Howard What to Do With RMDs From Three Retirement Accounts





